The idea of working for free under the guise of “getting clips” has always pissed me off.
I didn’t like it in my advertising class at MSU, when we competed with posters to win a campaign for an event on campus. The poster? Fine. But the winner then “had the opportunity” to design an additional postcard, t-shirt, and invite for the event. Crap.
I liked it less last year when my little brother, a junior in high school, told me the beat writer covering his community was republishing the articles they wrote for their journalism class in the “professional” paper down the road. Without paying them. Or asking their permission (she got them from their adviser, which is another story). Or editing the articles with them to help them improve. But whoopee, they got a byline in a crummy paper.
I don’t like the idea of unpaid internships. I understand that they happen and internships are good experience, but I think it really limits the pool of people who can take them. Who can afford to live for a summer without pay? Not I. It creates an economical divide, as if college weren’t enough to do that already.
_______________________________________________
While I often worked for clips in college, I have a degree now, and expect to be paid.
Which leads me to yesterday.
A friend of a friend (Some Guy), whom I had met once called me up and asked for help on a project. The conversation went something like this: (edited for details and because I have not yet mastered the art of memorizing conversation word for word)
Some guy: Hi, this is SG, we met that one night, I’m so-and-so’s friend?
Me: Yeah?
SG: Well, I know you’re a designer and I’m working on this Fake Headlines project and was wondering if you could help me.
Me, internally: What? This dude can’t write a headline?
Me, externally: Okay…
SG: Yeah well this woman is coming back to our office and we want to commemorate* it with this Fake Headline and I wondered if you could help.
Me: So you need something designed?
SG: Yeah, yeah.
Me: Well, not to be a jerk , but I don’t really work for free.
SG: Oh no, of course not, I was just wondering if you could take a look at it.
Me: Okay, well why don’t you email me what you have and a description of what you want and I can give you an estimate.
I immediately called my mother and went on a soap-box rant about how I don’t work for free. God Bless her.
_______________________________________________
When I got to work at my kick-ass (paid) design internship, I checked my e-mail. The guy seems nice, but I am so not interested in this “project.” He includes no details as to what he would like me to do.

Closely followed by this one:

So to recap:
I don’t really know this guy.
I still don’t know what this project is.
And, in case you were wondering, I had no intention of starting a project I still don’t understand “right away.” Or at all.
I sent him a reply with a rather high estimate of what I would charge for something like this, and later that day he told me he wouldn’t be needing my services after all. Shucks, there goes my clip.
_______________________________________________
The point is that working for free, even for your friends, is a dangerous road to go down. You do one wedding invitation, and suddenly everyone you went to college with wants you to do theirs.
I work for trades for close friends. Bake me some cookies, I’ll do your resume. You read my cover letter, I’ll fix your typography. And I think that’s fine. I’ll probably do my little brother’s graduation announcements next year, if he’ll let me. But I believe the more work you do for free, the more you are taking away from the industry.
How many times have you heard “you charge what? my brother/uncle/cousin/ex-boyfriend’s sister’s friend can do that in photoshop for free”?
_______________________________________________
List of things I’ve thought of that are the equivalent to designing for free:
- asking your friend the accountant to do your taxes for free
- asking your friend the teacher to tutor your kid, for free
- asking your friend the musical theatre major to sing and dance at your party for entertainment, for free
I think you get my point.